Australia's High Court has struck down the planning approval for an expansion of the Mount Pleasant coalmine in the Hunter Valley of New South Wales, ruling 3-2 that the state's planning commission failed to consider the emissions produced when exported coal is burned abroad. The case was brought by Dams Heg, a community group from the region, and it marks the first climate-related case decided by the country's highest court.
The mine, operated by MACH Energy near Muswellbrook, was set to roughly double its output to 21 million tonnes a year until 2048. The court found the assessment did not account for what are known as scope 3 emissions, the greenhouse gases released when coal is combusted by buyers overseas. Those emissions make up about 98 per cent of the project's projected total, according to the case materials, meaning the bulk of the mine's climate footprint sat outside the approval process.
The judgment rested on different reasoning from a earlier decision by the New South Wales Court of Appeal, and the dispute had been running for more than four years. Dams Heg said the ruling confirmed a direct link between coal sold for export and climate harm. Johnson Legal, which represented the group, argued that Australia must take responsibility for emissions from the coal it ships.
The decision has wider implications for the region. A Greens MP has said the extension of the neighbouring HVO mine, approved only last week, now faces similar legal risk, and reports indicate that the HVO impact statement left out scope 3 emissions entirely. MACH Energy said it was disappointed, is reviewing the judgment and is pursuing other options. Separately, New South Wales has approved a mine modification in August that extends the operation's life by six years. The Minerals Council of Australia described the ruling as a blow to demand for coal exports.
We rewrote this story on 4 November 2026 after an editorial review.
Credit. Based on reporting by Lisa Cox and Donna Lu for The Guardian. Is this your work? Write to us.
163





