Adults appear to be more creative than children, but they are considerably less sure of their own abilities, according to a new study that challenges the popular belief that young children are the most inventive people in the room.

The research was led by Benedek and colleagues at the University of Graz in Austria and published in the journal PLOS One. The team tested 92 children aged four to seven and 70 adults with an average age of 25. Participants completed three tasks: listing as many uses as they could for a tin can in three minutes, making a free drawing over eight minutes, and sketching an imaginary animal over another eight minutes. Five untrained raters scored the results for originality and for how well each response fulfilled the task.

Across the tasks, adults outscored the children overall. On the tin can task, adults averaged 3.9 out of 5 compared with 2.9 for the children. Adults also scored 0.6 and 1.9 points higher on the two later drawing tasks. The results suggest that creative output, at least as measured here, tends to grow with age and experience rather than fade.

The confidence gap was just as striking. Children rated their own performance far more generously than the adults rated theirs, and they reported much lower anxiety about how their work would be judged. Both groups enjoyed the imaginary animal task to the same degree, which indicates that the adults' lower self-assessment was not driven by less fun.

The researchers offered possible explanations but left some questions open. Adults may have had more prior knowledge to draw on when generating ideas, which could account for part of their advantage. It remains unclear whether the specific wording of the task instructions reduced the adults' worry about being judged, a factor that could have shaped how freely they worked.

We rewrote this story on 4 November 2026 after an editorial review.

Credit. Based on reporting by Carissa Wong for New Scientist. Is this your work? Write to us.

126Views

Logan Weston

Author

Sports Writer

Logan Weston covers public affairs, politics, business, culture and daily news for Science Official. The role focuses on verification, context, and clear explanations for readers.